Whose Terms Are You Trading On? A Board Review of Order Paperwork
Photo: business purchase order forms and contract documents with pen and glasses on office desk, via cdn.pixabay.com
In a great many UK businesses, the contract is not a document anyone has negotiated. It is a purchase order raised by a buyer, an acknowledgement stamped and returned by a supplier, a delivery note signed at the loading bay, and an invoice with three lines of small print at the foot of page two. Each of those documents may purport to bring in a set of standard terms. Which set governs is usually decided long before anybody thinks to ask.
The stack nobody reads as a set
Read individually, each document looks administrative. Read together, they are competing offers and acceptances. A purchase order that says goods are supplied on the buyer's terms, an acknowledgement that accepts the order on the supplier's terms, and an invoice that refers to terms on a website are three separate attempts to fix the basis of the deal. The company that wins the argument is not necessarily the one with the better lawyer; it is often the one whose paperwork was consistent and whose terms were properly brought to the other side's attention.
How terms get into a deal
There are four routes. The first is signature, which is why a signed quotation or framework agreement is worth more than a dozen printed forms. The second is reasonable notice: terms contained in a document that a party has actually seen, or has been told about in clear terms before or at the time of contracting, can be incorporated. The third is a course of dealing, where the parties have traded on the same printed terms for years without objection. The fourth is incorporation by reference, for example a reference in an order to terms published online, which only works if the other party had a realistic opportunity to read them.
What rarely works is the invoice that arrives with the goods and introduces terms for the first time. A term delivered after the contract has been formed generally comes too late to bind the buyer.
The battle of the forms
The classic illustration remains Butler Machine Tool v Ex-Cell-O in 1979, where a quotation with price variation clauses crossed with an order on the buyer's terms, and the dispute turned on which document was the last counter-offer accepted by conduct. The lesson is often summarised as the last document wins, but that is too simple. Courts look at whether the documents conflict, whether one side clearly accepted the other's terms, and how the parties behaved. The outcome can turn on something as small as a tear-off slip or a stamped acknowledgement.
Where the money actually hides
For a finance director, the terms question is a cash question. Payment terms sit at the top of the list: where no period is agreed, statute provides a default, and the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998 supplies a statutory interest rate and fixed compensation for late payment. Contracting out of that regime is possible, but it should be a decision, not an accident of whose form was used.
Set-off clauses come next. A buyer's terms may allow it to deduct the cost of defective goods from any invoice, including invoices for unrelated deliveries. A supplier's terms may forbid set-off entirely. The difference matters most in the month when cash is tight.
Retention of title is a third area. A clause purporting to retain ownership until payment is only useful if the goods remain identifiable and the clause is properly drafted and incorporated, as the Romalpa line of cases established. A retention clause buried in terms that never became part of the contract is decoration.
Price variation, delivery windows, risk transfer, liability caps and termination rights on insolvency complete the list. Each of them moves cash, and each of them is frequently on one party's form and absent from the other's.
A matching exercise worth doing once a year
Take the ten largest suppliers and the ten largest customers. For each, place the purchase order, the acknowledgement, the delivery note and a recent invoice side by side. Mark every point on which the documents disagree: payment days, delivery dates, liability, set-off, title, jurisdiction. Most boards find three or four recurring conflicts, and one or two that have been quietly costing money for years.
Controls that stop the problem recurring
Agree a house position on terms for each significant counterparty and record it centrally, so that purchasing and sales are working from the same document. Require any order placed on a counterparty's form to be reviewed before it is sent, not after the goods arrive. Train the warehouse and accounts teams to flag acknowledgements that come back stamped with unfamiliar terms. Escalate anything involving unlimited liability, indemnities or extended payment periods to a director. Finally, repeat the matching exercise annually as part of the board's commercial review, and minute the result.
The purpose is not to win a legal argument. It is to ensure that the terms governing a delivery, an invoice and a payment are the terms the board believes it agreed.