Larsen Howie All articles
Governance & Ownership

Three Years, One Declaration: Putting Auto-Enrolment Back on the Board Agenda

Larsen Howie
Three Years, One Declaration: Putting Auto-Enrolment Back on the Board Agenda

Photo: Francisclarke, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Most directors can say, without checking, when the company was incorporated and when the current financial year ends. Very few can say when the company next has to act on its automatic enrolment duties. That is not a criticism of payroll. It is a gap in board oversight, because the duty to enrol eligible staff belongs to the employer, and the employer acts through its directors.

A duty that does not switch off

Automatic enrolment is usually installed once, at the duties start date, and then left alone. The legislation does not work that way. Every employer has a continuing duty to assess its workforce each pay period, and a separate duty to re-enrol certain staff roughly every three years. Staff who opted out, or who ceased to be an active member, must generally be brought back in at the re-enrolment date. The employer then has to tell The Pensions Regulator that it has done so, by completing a re-declaration of compliance within five months of the third anniversary.

The practical difficulty is that the three-year cycle turns on records held in three different places: the payroll software, the pension provider portal and a folder of correspondence nobody has opened since the scheme was established. A director who asks one question, namely whether the next re-enrolment date is in the diary, will usually discover within an hour whether the underlying records are in a fit state.

Where the numbers quietly drift

Contribution calculations look mechanical until they are tested. Four areas account for most of the errors we see.

The first is the difference between the scheme's pensionable pay definition and the statutory minimum. A scheme may use basic pay, while the statutory test is applied to qualifying earnings between a lower and an upper threshold. If the two are not reconciled annually, a company can be paying what feels like a generous contribution while still falling short of the statutory minimum for some staff.

The second is variable pay. Overtime, commission, bonuses and shift premiums may fall inside qualifying earnings. Where they have been excluded at scheme setup and never revisited, the shortfall builds up across the year.

The third is the interaction with salary sacrifice. A sacrifice arrangement reduces pay for pension purposes, but it cannot lawfully take a worker below the National Minimum Wage or National Living Wage. Arrangements put in place several years ago, before wage rates rose, deserve a fresh look.

The fourth is the treatment of staff who earn below the earnings trigger. They are not automatically enrolled, but if they ask to join, the employer must enrol them and pay contributions. Requests of this kind are sometimes handled informally and never reach the pension provider.

Opt-outs, refunds and the record that matters

An eligible jobholder may opt out, but only within the prescribed window and only through the pension provider's process. Where a valid opt-out is received in the first month, contributions are refunded. Inducement to opt out is prohibited, which means that a line in a contract or a remark during induction can become a compliance problem in its own right.

The regulator expects opt-out notices to be kept for at least six years, alongside records of contributions and of the enrolment communications sent to staff. In practice the notices are often held by the provider and the communications by nobody. A short review should establish which party holds which record, and whether the company could produce a complete set if asked.

The evidence file

A useful discipline is to build a single pension file, reviewed annually, containing the duties start date, the re-enrolment dates for the current and next cycle, the scheme's contribution basis, the latest declaration or re-declaration reference, the most recent payroll assessment report and a sample of enrolment letters. If the file cannot be assembled in an afternoon, the process is probably dependent on one person's memory.

A one-hour review for the board

  1. Confirm the next re-enrolment date and the latest date for re-declaration, and place both in the board calendar with a named owner.
  2. Ask payroll to demonstrate the contribution calculation for one variable-pay employee and one salaried employee, at the statutory minimum.
  3. Reconcile the scheme's pensionable pay definition against the statutory test.
  4. Confirm how requests to join, and opt-out notices, are logged and where they are stored.
  5. Check that salary sacrifice arrangements remain compatible with current wage rates.
  6. Record the review in the board minutes, with the date of the next one.

When the regulator writes

The Pensions Regulator works largely from data returns and referrals, and its first contact is usually a request for information rather than a penalty. A fixed penalty of £400 is the standard starting point for a failure to complete a declaration, with escalating daily penalties where the failure continues. Unpaid contributions can be pursued through the courts, and directors can be named.

None of that is proportionate to the size of most small companies, which is precisely why the cheapest control is the annual hour. A company that can produce a dated file, a named owner and a minuted review is in a very different position from one that is reconstructing events after the letter has arrived.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Shopfront Behind the Screen: A Director’s Annual Review of Website Terms and Online Sales

The Shopfront Behind the Screen: A Director’s Annual Review of Website Terms and Online Sales

Permission to Trade: The Board Register for Licences, Registrations and Memberships

Permission to Trade: The Board Register for Licences, Registrations and Memberships

Custody Is Not Ownership: Building a Board-Level Register of Digital Assets

Custody Is Not Ownership: Building a Board-Level Register of Digital Assets